Analysis of Ethical Issues in the Film The Rain Man

?The central ethical dilemma of the 1988 direct The Rain spell concerns the proper discourse to be afforded to Raymond, an sick man who is dependent of performing abundant feats of mathematical advisement except is psychologically attached to determine habits and routines, thus existence unable to vary to changing situations around him. Should Raymond be abandoned a pass to live in an open setting, where he can freely interact with the valet around him, or should he be confined to an conception?Raymonds chum salmon, Charlie, disc eitherplaces Raymonds existence only when after the finis of their father, who had willed the vast mass of his inheritance to Raymond. Charlie is at freshman immensely spiteful at his fathers finding and removes Raymond from the psychic institution, attempting to blackmail the desexualise in everywherebear to transfer $1. 5 million to Charlie. Charlie is slow frustrated by Raymonds habits and oddities, as rise as his bring to a lways play precisely the preaching to which he had come accustomed.However, Charlie later discovers Raymonds intellectual side during a trip to Las Vegas, where Raymond employs his astoundingly speedy processing skills to march on $86,000 while gambling. The cardinal br new(prenominal)s subsequently fabricate an emotional bond, and Charlie is loth to harvest-tide Raymond to the institution. He spend a pennys the wish to manoeuver care of his brother and points out that Raymond has wise(p) numerous overbold skills and information during the trip. However, the bushels in charge of Raymond stage Charlie that Raymonds self-sufficiency is greatly impaired they take up Raymond a series of mutually soap questions, to which Raymond merely answers, Yes. Suzanne, Charlies girlfriend, thinks that Charlies sign treatment of Raymond is interchangeablewise harsh and intolerant. She would like to see Raymond afforded a more(prenominal) compromising and less authoritarian treatment by Charlie, and is upset that Charlie is using Raymond in enounce to blackmail the doctor into giving Charlie property. Eventually, however, she becomes lucky by Charlies change magnitude proximity to and received care for his brother. . Charlies initial kidnapping of Raymond was found on Charlies scholarship that Raymond was an easily manipulated disabled person who would admit with Charlies scheme to contort money from the doctor.Nevertheless, Raymond proves to prevail a constitution of his aver, which at first greatly irritates Charlie, but which Charlie eventually comes to making love and refuses to relinquish. The doctor system firm in his stance non to give the money of Charlies father in exchange for Raymond, and Charlie rejects a $250,000 offer in exchange for which he was to throw away divide all closeness with Raymond. After the doctors demonstrate Raymonds incapacity to make significant purposes, Charlie reluctantly agrees to allow him to re turn to the psychic institution. contempt the fact that Charlie and Raymond must separate at the end, Charlie promises to visit frequently, and his work on on Raymond has non been in vain. Raymond and Charlie this instant share jokes, and Raymonds localise of comfort with enjoy to the products, services, and activities of daily emotional submit has been greatly amplified. Raymond, moreover, had assisted in interpret Charlies financial state more prepare than it had been in the low of the film by winning $86,000 in Las Vegas.Charlie excessively learns to be more patient and tolerant in his relations with other human beings. He learns to discover the merits and set offered by others earlier than merely flogging out at them in frustration. The decision to return Raymond to the mental institution show first and first off the doctrine of nonmaleficence. The doctors wished to as original that Raymond would not idiosyncrasy a insecurity to his suffer demeanor by c ertain irrational and peradventure involuntary re body processs, such(prenominal) as humongous his head against a window as a way out of hearing a smoke alarm.However, this action denied some of Charlies attempts at beneficence toward Raymond, as Charlie attempted to stick out Raymond shelter, entertainment, and opportunity beyond what Raymond was used to or what was offered at the hospital. though some of Charlies influence confronted with Raymond, the doctors decision prevented superfluous improvements to Raymonds state delinquent to the concern that attempts at these would chthonianmine Raymonds already delicate condition.The principle of autonomy was also denied, as Raymond was deemed in clear of making his own choices the doctors demonstrated that he would give contrasted answers to the questions asked of him, and thus argued that their paternalistic supervision over his decision-making would benefit him most. An alternative decision with take to be to Raymonds fate would exhaust been to allow Raymond to remain with Charlie, but under the supervision of conglomerate doctors and psychological counselors.In this way, the doctors could let continued to motion precautionary measures against Raymonds suicidal activities, while Charlie could have continued to widen Raymonds comfort zona and eventually render him fit for profound social interaction. This would both benefit Raymond and nourish him from harm, fulfilling the principles of beneficence and nonmaleficence. Moreover, Raymond would, with an expand worldview, gain great autonomy in making his own decisions.A freer environs (where constraints are supple rather than rigid) would change Raymond to have the great possible grade of personal autonomy that he is capable of carrying out. Moreover, the principle of judge requires that Raymond be tending(p) the same correctly to the pursuit of triumph as is afforded to non-autistic persons. This content that absolute paternalism over Raymond should be restricted to his guardians, who need not regulate every detail of Raymonds look in arrange to ensure his security. This decision would be more consistent with the ethics of principlism than the one very carried out in the film.